22 March, 1999
Washington, DC
Members present were:
The first topic of discussion was a review of the workshop and lessons
learned. It was noted that the workshop had been held on Tuesday in the
past, rather than on Monday as scheduled this year. The change was
necessitated this year by FAA's shift in its meeting to Wednesday-Thursday,
moving ATRIF to Tuesday, and thereby leaving Monday as our option for our
meeting. It was felt that attracting attendees to a Monday meeting was a
difficult proposition.
David Brandt mentioned that last year's good attendance (130, with 98
paid), resulted partly from a late "blitz" of publicity undertaken by AIAA
headquarters in the interest of assuring a successful meeting, but that
AIAA management had felt similar resources could not prudently be expended
this year. Efforts to attract more ATRIF members to attend, via an e-mail
invitation extending the reduced registration fee, were made, but with
insufficient results to lead to a enough of a turnout to proceed with the
workshop. It was noted that our workshop topic did not 'resonate'
particularly with this year's ATRIF theme (Dynamics of the Narrowbody
Market), and this, too, was a factor. There was some feeling expressed,
too, that our workshop topic/title, "Commercial and Military Air
Transportation: Meeting the Challenges Together", was not evocative to a
broad enough segment of the 'market' of potential attendees to attract a
large attendance.
With regard to the dearth of registrants from the military airlift area,
Barry Creighton expressed the opinion that we were hurt by the lack of any
identification with traditional military organizations......Air Force
Association, etc. This made participation of USAF representatives from
outside the Washington area more problematic. Members who contacted the
slated speakers to advise them of the cancellation of the workshop related
that the news was met with understanding and appreciation for not
proceeding with the small expected audience.
With respect to next year's workshop, it was resolved to determine ASAP
what FAA's schedule would be and to hold open our decision as to how to
proceed until more is known about this schedule, etc. (See postscript
below re ATRIF discussion.) Further rounding out the discussion of the
Workshop, Tony Hays brought up the concept of an on-line forum, possibly to
be sponsored by the TC, facilitating exchange of ideas and information
among people working in various disciplines, as an adjunct to our
sponsorship of 'live' workshops. Joe Davis mentioned that there is an
Aviation Special Interest Group (AVSIG) on CompuServe, as well as an
Aviation Week Group site that might be of interest to TC members. (The Av
Week site is www.aviationweek.com will advise the www. for Compuserve
AVSIG forum later. JTD).
The discussion moved to the topic of participation in the WAC meeting in
San Francisco in October (Oct. 19-21, 1999). Dimitri Mavris committed to
chairing a session to be assembled from the 'wreckage' of the Workshop,
i.e. inviting presenters from the workshop to, instead, present a talk (not
necessarily a written paper) at the conference. Barry Creighton committed
to contact potential speakers and to pass on to Dimitri their responses and
contact info within a few days, since the deadline for the WAC program is
April 1. With the session being organized by George Donohue on the subject
of aerial gridlock, this means our TC will be responsible for two sessions
at this year's WAC.
Regarding the next TC meeting, it was agreed that this should occur in
conjunction with the Global Air and Space meeting, May 3-5, in Washington.
Emily Davies committed to search for an appropriate meeting place for May
5. It is planned to provide for teleconferencing this meeting to involve
those TC members not able to attend in person.
Chairman Ausrotas announced that he would ask Joe Windisch, now in the
process of moving to San Antonio, to again shoulder the job of writing the
TC's contribution to the annual Highlights for Air and Space Magazine.
Members are requested to forward to Joe any news items that they feel may
be helpful to him in this task. (Joe, please send us your new mailing
address, phone number, etc. when you get settled......assume e-mail address
is still Jjwind@aol.com)
Ray suggested that all TC members give some thought to possible topics for
next year's Workshop, and also to think about selection of a new TC
Chairperson to take over from him in May, 2000.
Barry Creighton reported that selection of the Jay Hollingsworth Speas
Award recipient has been accomplished on an expedited basis, in order that
the award may be given at the May Air and Space meeting in Washington; he
expressed thanks to David Bryant for his assistance in keeping the process
on a fast track.
The two guests at the session, Steve Hooker and Alfredo Colon, led a
discussion of concepts presented in a draft paper, 'Closing the
Transportation Gap in the XXI Century', dealing with a search for
intercontinental heavy-lift transport capability somewhere in the
intermediate speed/cost range between the extremes of surface ships (slow
but cheap) and current air transports (fast but costly). Surface effect
vehicles operating in the 100 to 300 knot speed range just above the
surface of the ocean seem to have some potential, and the conversation
centered on this technology, some of which, members will recall, was
presented in one of our workshops (Spring '95?). Funding is a major
obstacle to be dealt with in pursuit of this technology.
The meeting was adjourned at 10:15 PM, with thanks to the AIAA hosts for
their hospitality.
Respectfully submitted,
Post Script: Subsequent to the meeting, on Tuesday, Ausrotas/Hays
approached the ATRIF officers to discuss the question of future
collaboration on our Spring Washington meetings versus maintaining linkage
to the FAA Forecast Meeting, etc. ATRIF leadership's initial response was
quite positive to the concept of maintaining TC-ATS/ATRIF cooperation and
coupling our meetings to the May AIAA Global Air and Space events, rather
to the FAA forecast sessions. Conceptually, this would make a five-day week
in early May, 2000........Monday through Wednesday for Global Air and
Space, and Thursday-Friday for the ATRIF meeting and our TC Workshop.
(Brochures for this May's AIAA event were passed on to ATRIF leaders to
better acquaint them with the nature of these meetings.) ATRIF leaders
committed to give the concept serious consideration in their next Board of
Directors discussion.
The Chairman convened the meeting at 8:25 PM, following dinner at Blackies
House of Beef.
Joe Davis
March 24, 1999